By Brandon Matthews
Is the media deal of the century about to take place? According to a Reuters news report, Greg Maffei of Liberty Media (LINTA) expects to “spin-off” Liberty’s preferred stake in Sirius XM Radio, which represents a 40 percent interest in the company, “at some point.”
I have been speculating about this since last April, when I first wrote about the prospects of Sirius XM Radio (SIRI) reversing the February deal with Liberty Capital (LCAPA) that staved off bankruptcy.
My suspicions began while reviewing the details of the original credit agreement between Liberty and Sirius XM, which allows for the termination of the agreement up until Dec 31, 2009. This December deadline had stuck out to me as a potential deadline that was agreed to behind closed doors.
Sirius XM Radio has gone to great lengths throughout 2009 to completely repay Liberty Capital under the terms of this agreement. The only remaining issue is what Liberty intends to do with its 40 percent preferred stake, acquired for a mere $12,500, but now valued at approximately $1 billion. With so much profit having already been attained, tax issues would seem to be a moot point, which creates endless possibilities for the disposition of the preferred shares.
When the preferred shares were issued, the price of SIRI shares dropped, as if the preferred shares were already converted to common. In other words, the current share price reflects dilution that hasn’t taken place yet. Maffei’s statement that Liberty will be looking to “spin-off” that stake makes clear that Liberty has no intention of converting those shares to common.
Although the preferred stake is worth 40 percent of Sirius XM Radio’s current market cap, the shares cannot realistically be converted and sold in the market at current market prices. The flood of shares being sold would significantly lower their price, so the preferred stake can likely be repurchased for somewhat less than its current market value.
Now that we know Liberty will seek to unwind its position in Sirius XM, this leaves only two concerns in my mind: How likely is this to occur? And where will Sirius XM get the money for such a deal?
When we look at the relationship of Sirius XM and Liberty, as it has been publicly displayed, it appears to be very good. Liberty execs Maffei and John Malone sit on Sirius XM Radio’s Board of Directors. There also appears to be a swap of executives under way. As former Direct TV (DTV) Chairman and CEO Eddie Hartenstein takes over as the chairman of Sirius XM Radio’s Board of Directors, and I suspect the just-resigned chair, Gary Parsons, will be heading over to Direct TV, which was also a Liberty holding. The relationship of these media moguls suggests that an internal deal can be reached with relative ease.
Which brings us to the point of Sirius XM Radio and its ability to pay for such a deal. Earlier in the year, shareholders approved an additional 1 billion shares to be authorized. I subsequently proposed that Sirius XM Radio could use those shares to raise the capital to repurchase Liberty’s preferred stake. According to the credit agreement which is now in effect dissolved with the repayment of the outstanding debt, Liberty would simply have to approve the sale of shares. I can find no current reason that such shares could not be issued otherwise.
Shareholder dilution is usually a bad thing for investors. In this case, though, reverse dilution would occur. There could also be a deal that involves debt and equity, further reducing the equity costs of such a transaction. Sirius XM has been advantageously repurchasing its own debt, and Liberty has been buying Sirius XM bonds this year, as well.
The effects of such a deal, if it does in fact come to fruition, would catapult Sirius XM shares to a level that would remove any reverse split or delisting fears that may exist in the marketplace. I would expect to see Liberty Media first return its stake to Liberty Capital, after which time I suspect we will see either a slow repurchase of Liberty’s preferred stake by Sirius XM Radio, or the media deal of the century. Someone will be buying that stake. It might as well be Sirius XM itself.
Position: Long SIRI
















































Very, very interesting…So this would have to be completed by dec 31 this year Brandon?
Im a novice, but a reverse split, done to vastly reduce the number of shares outstanding(ala Priceline) wouldnt be a good thing for shareholders?(im beginning to think its not all bad) I know the PPS would increase too but why is it so bad for this particular company? Thanks in advance Brandon–Love the site
Brandon which is it…is the stake priced in or not
“When the preferred shares were issued, the price of SIRI shares dropped, as if the preferred shares were already converted to common. In other words, the current share price reflects dilution that hasn’t taken place yet.”
Or
“Although the preferred stake is worth 40 percent of Sirius XM Radio’s current market cap, the shares cannot realistically be converted and sold in the market at current market prices. The flood of shares being sold would significantly lower their price, so the preferred stake can likely be repurchased for somewhat less than its current market value.”
jamesey
The answer can be both…yes…when the deal was announced…the sp took a significant hit…now fast forward…if the shares are converted…it would not necessarily affect sp…what Brandon is stating is…if these shares are sold on the open market after being converted…If someone was to sell 2.6B shares of any company…the sp would plummet!
Fascinating times for Sirius XM and holders of SIRI – all very favorable and exciting.
The company can develop in many alternative ways and the close relationship with Liberty appears to be a real source of strength.
Brandon, is it not possible that Sirius Xm buys back a portion of those shares but also then sell a smaller stake to an interested company that would have some synergies by owning say 25% of Sirius Xm and a seat or two on the board? With Sirius Xm turning the corner in a positive direction a 25% stake in this company be worth much more than it did in Feb.? It could be a win win with a company like Apple or a large advertising based media company that needs to diversify?
market supply and equity dilution….2 different things….
lots of possibilities….Cos put forth a scenario in which the NOL’s could be used to fund the repurchase..I like that scenario as well.
That is interesting? Don’t know how that is possible under the IRS code. NOL’s cannot be separated from the entity for which they were incurred…IMPO For Liberty to take advantage of the NOL’s they would have to maintain some kind of ownership or controlling interest in the entity for which they were incurred. NOL’s are not assets in the traditional sense…not a building, etc. they are “tax benefits” that attach to the entity for which they were incurred…impo
In my opinion, if a deal does go down as outlined in the article it would be a life changing event for Sirius XM and it’s shareholders. This almost overnight would send all the naysayers and shorts running for cover and rightly place Sirius XM in the marketplace where it should be.
Very interesting article, we can only hope that it bears fruit. For now in my book, this is the article of the year for Sirius XM as it ties everything together and explains many things that this novice has been thinking about.
Long SIRI
Just wanted to comment real quick. Maffei is not talking about selling the stake. Spin off means moving the stake to another tracking company, probably the one being created for Worldspace assets…etc…
All hes talking about here
Nothing to do with selling anything to anyone.
They may in the future, but regardless, not what hes talking about. He misinterpreted his comments 100 percent.
Interesting theory. However, there being a date of December 31, 2009 I don’t think means such date can not be extended by agreement of the parties to the original agreement.
the dec. 31 st date is non existent,it was reffered to the first phase of liberty deal in feb not being done so 2nd phase could close,that is what the date is about,but the 2nd phase of Liberty deal was closed,so it means nothing at all,non-event just new years eve is all….
I remember reading that SIRI would be added to a tracking stock that contained DTV.
While the dilution talk might sound contradictory, it actually is not. Without releasing another share into the float, if I went out and sold 100 million shares, the stock price would drop dramatically. If Liberty tried to sell their 3 BILLION shares… it would be even worse. Again, Im not talking about CONVERSION, Im talking about actually SELLING the shares.
As far as conversion goes, all analysts already have the Liberty dilution baked in as part of their valuations because the use of Enterprise Value takes the preferred shares into account.
Very interesting Brandon and I certainly hope you are right…that would be great for SIRIUS shareholders. However, with that said, I see Maffei’s remarks as being more consistent with what they are doing with DTV…in order to keep their interest in the NOL’s…if that happens its basically a non event for SIRIUS shareholders…in any case, the future remains very bright for SIRIUS…IMPO
I’m sorry Brandon, but this article is not on target. John Malone is not giving back the equity.
I completely agree. Why does he think that somehow Liberty spinning off their SiriusXM stake means that they are selling it back to Sirus? What’s the connection?
Brandon, why in the world would you take the leap from Liberty “spinning off” their Sirius stake to Sirius buying that stake back? There’s no connection between those two events.
Well obviously you are new to Satwave and Brandon Mathews. It’s called bend over and spread your cheeks so he can pump more sunshine up your ass. Do you get it now?
It’s amazing to me that no one has posted or looked into the obvious that why is a .67 penny stock getting this much attention. The street.com through the day posted 10 different articles by various flunky, I guess you could call them journalists, MotleyFool posts 2-3 a day and no one asks why all the attention to this penny stock. It begs the question, what’s really going on here. Anybody have a clue.
If there were any validity to this scenario we would have exploded today.
The Liberty/Sirius deal has been a phenominal success no matter the course Liberty takes. It should be clear from all the discussion in the last 24 hours is that there’s no sense in dumping the shares on the market and much more profitable to sell it back to Sirius. There’s a third possibility. By working Sirius content into a Worldspace expansion or creating some other partnership(s) with Liberty, it’ll add value (and market cap) to Sirius. Sirius may be a monopoly but it’s not an island. Sirius is one of the largest market caps on the NASDAQ, we’ve started seeing partnerships taking on new dimensions.
Well, if the plan was to keep Ergin from taking control; putting some coin in Liberty’s pocket. They have done both!
Liberty has other plans, note the purchase of German cable company! They need cash for this deal and to continue to purchase other distressed assets for his empire!
I can see this deal going through and selling back the stake to Sirius! Where else are you going to make 750 million dollars in 9 months!
I guess we will all see within a month and a half.
I agree spin off doesn’t mean sell off. Doesn’t it mean move it to another branch of the company? Let’s not make wrong moves here.
Absolutely can’t figure why Liberty would let go of something it got.